{ "reviewer": "Codex", "human_review_claimed": false, "followup_all_off_correct_on_wrong": { "utc": "2026-10-31T06:46:14.794968+00:00", "reviewer": "Codex", "human_review_claimed": false, "source_audit_sha256": "7e3860bd61cb3bb88707e58b81c8c0e0b015cd79d38be936f3377d576707ef07", "source_results_sha256": "4a7c0cc27555bbf233e9766c9256c3d271a0284333ff863cfee9ad025e24355e", "all_off_correct_on_wrong_pairs_reviewed": true, "all_evidence_reconciled": true, "case015_verified": true, "off_correct_on_wrong_pairs": 2, "unique_task_seed_combinations": 1, "all_paired_outcomes": { "input4096-cap4096": { "pairs": 36, "both_correct": 30, "off_only_correct": 0, "on_only_correct": 1, "both_wrong": 5, "complete_sequence_identical": 13 }, "input4096-cap8192": { "pairs": 36, "both_correct": 30, "off_only_correct": 0, "on_only_correct": 1, "both_wrong": 5, "complete_sequence_identical": 13 }, "input32768-cap4096": { "pairs": 36, "both_correct": 0, "off_only_correct": 1, "on_only_correct": 3, "both_wrong": 32, "complete_sequence_identical": 0 }, "input32768-cap8192": { "pairs": 36, "both_correct": 0, "off_only_correct": 1, "on_only_correct": 3, "both_wrong": 32, "complete_sequence_identical": 0 } }, "pairs": [ { "task": "long-records-015", "seed": 289116, "max_generation": 4096, "review": { "category": "wrong_column_copy", "finding_ja": "対象215行のIDは両方一度ずつ列挙。ありは38行で件数ではなく同じ行の待ち秒を転記し、そのリストの合計11535を回答。なしの11482が正解。両上限とも自然終了。", "review_receipt": "output-cap-discordant-case015-r2-mechanism-review.json", "review_receipt_sha256": "33f8ea1aa773156e69cd6c20f7264d1f4949581facd748f0149d63bc88616ac6", "evidence_strength": "emitted_list_reconciled_against_all_target_source_rows" }, "off": { "case": "main-long-records-015-cap4096-sampling-r2-mtp0", "phase": "main", "max_generation": 4096, "task": "long-records-015", "category": "grounded_long_records", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 289116, "rep": 2, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 32768, "generated_tokens": 3705, "first_generated_seconds": 11.084076575003564, "first_visible_seconds": 11.084076575003564, "first_answer_seconds": 85.80515068001114, "end_to_end_seconds": 86.81465896905866, "generation_tps": 48.90038906079581, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "dd8a06b8f77f009c8c4fe9956e66e7ac0b12cb14c1f5aa7dd6a9832456c35afa", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":{\"行数\":600,\"最小待ち秒\":1,\"最大待ち秒\":80,\"対象部署の件数合計\":11482,\"指定IDの待ち秒\":71,\"遅延原因\":\"不明\"}}", "parsed": { "answer": { "行数": 600, "最小待ち秒": 1, "最大待ち秒": 80, "対象部署の件数合計": 11482, "指定IDの待ち秒": 71, "遅延原因": "不明" } }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true }, "complete_token_sequence_sha256": "be70e6aff32bd50477fc1a6282788e5f321ef0a31c528cf37d4545ffce87f9e2", "input_target": 32768, "full_completion": "Count lines: 600. Min wait: 1, max: 80. 管理件数合計: need count. ID512: 71秒. That's heavy—need sum of 管理 counts. Let me count 管理 entries and sums.\n\n管理 ids: 1,9,11,17,20,23,30,35,36,37,38,40,43,44,45,47,52,54,55,60,61,66,69,74,79,80,82,83,84,87,91,94,97,98,109,110,116,117,120,126,127,130,131,132,133,136,140,141,143,145,146,150,153,156,160,161,163,164,167,171,174,176,178,179,182,183,187,205,207,210,214,216,217,219,221,222,224,225,231,235,236,239,242,243,245,246,251,253,260,261,264,266,275,276,284,286,288,290,296,297,301,302,304,318,320,322,323,324,330,331,335,339,341,343,346,348,354,355,356,358,359,360,361,366,369,372,382,383,385,388,389,390,391,400,402,403,405,409,410,411,415,416,422,423,427,430,435,436,437,444,448,450,452,453,457,459,465,469,472,473,480,484,485,487,488,501,502,504,505,507,510,512,513,516,517,518,521,523,526,528,532,533,536,537,540,542,544,546,548,554,557,561,562,563,565,568,569,570,577,579,580,581,582,583,584,585,586,588,589,590,593,595,596,597,599.\n\nCount them: let me count in groups.\nGroup 1-100: ids 1,9,11,17,20,23,30,35,36,37,38,40,43,44,45,47,52,54,55,60,61,66,69,74,79,80,82,83,84,87,91,94,97,98 → 34.\n101-200: 109,110,116,117,120,126,127,130,131,132,133,136,140,141,143,145,146,150,153,156,160,161,163,164,167,171,174,176,178,179,182,183,187 → 33.\n201-300: 205,207,210,214,216,217,219,221,222,224,225,231,235,236,239,242,243,245,246,251,253,260,261,264,266,275,276,284,286,288,290,296,297 → 33.\n301-400: 301,302,304,318,320,322,323,324,330,331,335,339,341,343,346,348,354,355,356,358,359,360,361,366,369,372,382,383,385,388,389,390,391,400 → 34.\n401-500: 402,403,405,409,410,411,415,416,422,423,427,430,435,436,437,444,448,450,452,453,457,459,465,469,472,473,480,484,485,487,488 → 31.\n501-600: 501,502,504,505,507,510,512,513,516,517,518,521,523,526,528,532,533,536,537,540,542,544,546,548,554,557,561,562,563,565,568,569,570,577,579,580,581,582,583,584,585,586,588,589,590,593,595,596,597,599 → 50.\nTotal = 34+33+33+34+31+50 = 215.\n\nNow sum counts for each 管理 line.\n\n1-100 group:\n1:83\n9:72\n11:40\n17:94\n20:61\n23:60\n30:100\n35:95\n36:57\n37:25\n38:18\n40:93\n43:25\n44:99\n45:58\n47:87\n52:31\n54:70\n55:80\n60:80\n61:10\n66:29\n69:78\n74:8\n79:93\n80:57\n82:34\n83:66\n84:37\n87:43\n91:69\n94:100\n97:65\n98:64\n\nSum: 83+72=155; +40=195; +94=289; +61=350; +60=410; +100=510; +95=605; +57=662; +25=687; +18=705; +93=798; +25=823; +99=922; +58=980; +87=1067; +31=1098; +70=1168; +80=1248; +80=1328; +10=1338; +29=1367; +78=1445; +8=1453; +93=1546; +57=1603; +34=1637; +66=1703; +37=1740; +43=1783; +69=1852; +100=1952; +65=2017; +64=2081.\n\n101-200:\n109:16\n110:69\n116:83\n117:98\n120:98\n126:22\n127:70\n130:7\n131:27\n132:79\n133:60\n136:77\n140:6\n141:3\n143:42\n145:80\n146:21\n150:88\n153:50\n156:7\n160:83\n161:70\n163:87\n164:44\n167:47\n171:21\n174:19\n176:50\n178:18\n179:83\n182:54\n183:84\n187:74\n\nSum: 16+69=85;+83=168;+98=266;+98=364;+22=386;+70=456;+7=463;+27=490;+79=569;+60=629;+77=706;+6=712;+3=715;+42=757;+80=837;+21=858;+88=946;+50=996;+7=1003;+83=1086;+70=1156;+87=1243;+44=1287;+47=1334;+21=1355;+19=1374;+50=1424;+18=1442;+83=1525;+54=1579;+84=1663;+74=1737.\n\nRunning total: 2081+1737=3818.\n\n201-300:\n205:83\n207:48\n210:22\n214:34\n216:63\n217:86\n219:71\n221:31\n222:55\n224:74\n225:16\n231:38\n235:42\n236:22\n239:40\n242:12\n243:39\n245:34\n246:86\n251:66\n253:82\n260:41\n261:53\n264:1\n266:32\n275:34\n276:71\n284:95\n286:40\n288:78\n290:60\n296:82\n297:50\n\nSum: 83+48=131;+22=153;+34=187;+63=250;+86=336;+71=407;+31=438;+55=493;+74=567;+16=583;+38=621;+42=663;+22=685;+40=725;+12=737;+39=776;+34=810;+86=896;+66=962;+82=1044;+41=1085;+53=1138;+1=1139;+32=1171;+34=1205;+71=1276;+95=1371;+40=1411;+78=1489;+60=1549;+82=1631;+50=1681.\n\nTotal: 3818+1681=5499.\n\n301-400:\n301:51\n302:48\n304:98\n318:55\n320:3\n322:42\n323:7\n324:51\n330:62\n331:44\n335:47\n339:74\n341:21\n343:59\n346:90\n348:96\n354:75\n355:53\n356:72\n358:33\n359:3\n360:5\n361:59\n366:28\n369:66\n372:79\n382:46\n383:9\n385:23\n388:84\n389:42\n390:60\n391:6\n400:24\n\nSum: 51+48=99;+98=197;+55=252;+3=255;+42=297;+7=304;+51=355;+62=417;+44=461;+47=508;+74=582;+21=603;+59=662;+90=752;+96=848;+75=923;+53=976;+72=1048;+33=1081;+3=1084;+5=1089;+59=1148;+28=1176;+66=1242;+79=1321;+46=1367;+9=1376;+23=1399;+84=1483;+42=1525;+60=1585;+6=1591;+24=1615.\n\nTotal: 5499+1615=7114.\n\n401-500:\n402:49\n403:3\n405:39\n409:71\n410:52\n411:25\n415:21\n416:83\n422:74\n423:66\n427:5\n430:98\n435:100\n436:88\n437:52\n444:86\n448:48\n450:61\n452:44\n453:76\n457:24\n459:59\n465:45\n469:78\n472:19\n473:42\n480:37\n484:65\n485:85\n487:92\n488:44\n\nSum: 49+3=52;+39=91;+71=162;+52=214;+25=239;+21=260;+83=343;+74=417;+66=483;+5=488;+98=586;+100=686;+88=774;+52=826;+86=912;+48=960;+61=1021;+44=1065;+76=1141;+24=1165;+59=1224;+45=1269;+78=1347;+19=1366;+42=1408;+37=1445;+65=1510;+85=1595;+92=1687;+44=1731.\n\nTotal: 7114+1731=8845.\n\n501-600:\n501:21\n502:81\n504:69\n505:26\n507:90\n510:80\n512:84\n513:20\n516:8\n517:37\n518:41\n521:66\n523:74\n526:22\n528:43\n532:62\n533:69\n536:8\n537:79\n540:58\n542:58\n544:83\n546:8\n548:47\n554:36\n557:40\n561:63\n562:43\n563:6\n565:35\n568:80\n569:4\n570:24\n577:44\n579:60\n580:44\n581:84\n582:67\n583:77\n584:71\n585:89\n586:66\n588:95\n589:87\n590:34\n593:84\n595:64\n596:20\n597:44\n599:42\n\nSum: 21+81=102;+69=171;+26=197;+90=287;+80=367;+84=451;+20=471;+8=479;+37=516;+41=557;+66=623;+74=697;+22=719;+43=762;+62=824;+69=893;+8=901;+79=980;+58=1038;+58=1096;+83=1179;+8=1187;+47=1234;+36=1270;+40=1310;+63=1373;+43=1416;+6=1422;+35=1457;+80=1537;+4=1541;+24=1565;+44=1609;+60=1669;+44=1713;+84=1797;+67=1864;+77=1941;+71=2012;+89=2101;+66=2167;+95=2262;+87=2349;+34=2383;+84=2467;+64=2531;+20=2551;+44=2595;+42=2637.\n\nTotal: 8845+2637=11482.\n\nAnswer: {\"行数\":600,\"最小待ち秒\":1,\"最大待ち秒\":80,\"対象部署の件数合計\":11482,\"指定IDの待ち秒\":71,\"遅延原因\":\"不明\"}{\"answer\":{\"行数\":600,\"最小待ち秒\":1,\"最大待ち秒\":80,\"対象部署の件数合計\":11482,\"指定IDの待ち秒\":71,\"遅延原因\":\"不明\"}}" }, "on": { "case": "main-long-records-015-cap4096-sampling-r2-mtp1", "phase": "main", "max_generation": 4096, "task": "long-records-015", "category": "grounded_long_records", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 289116, "rep": 2, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 32768, "generated_tokens": 2887, "first_generated_seconds": 11.418474373989739, "first_visible_seconds": 11.418474373989739, "first_answer_seconds": 44.89141746493988, "end_to_end_seconds": 45.355748873902485, "generation_tps": 84.96200217295043, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 1940, "rejected_draft_tokens": 901, "output_sha256": "6c24bb6968f61c3e518c0968ed5e8c9daecf841c5c7f21a08fc806305e32184e", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":{\"行数\":600,\"最小待ち秒\":1,\"最大待ち秒\":80,\"対象部署の件数合計\":11535,\"指定IDの待ち秒\":71,\"遅延原因\":\"不明\"}}", "parsed": { "answer": { "行数": 600, "最小待ち秒": 1, "最大待ち秒": 80, "対象部署の件数合計": 11535, "指定IDの待ち秒": 71, "遅延原因": "不明" } }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false }, "complete_token_sequence_sha256": "73d32dfc9ea8f28ffb623ea3f7c55a71077835944c95c640943c4f65ad7e4f45", "input_target": 32768, "full_completion": "Count lines: 600. Min wait: 1, max: 80. 管理件数合計 — need to sum 管理件数. ID512: 71. 遅延原因: 不明.\n\nSum 管理件数: let's list 管理 ids and 件数:\n1:83,9:72,11:40,17:94,20:61,23:60,30:100,35:95,36:57,37:25,38:18,40:93,43:25,44:99,45:58,47:87,52:31,54:70,55:80,60:80,61:10,66:29,69:78,74:8,79:93,80:57,82:34,83:66,84:33,87:32,91:64,94:100,97:65,98:64,109:16,110:69,116:83,117:98,120:98,126:22,127:70,130:7,131:27,132:79,133:55,136:77,140:78,141:3,143:55,145:80,146:21,150:88,153:50,156:7,160:83,161:70,163:87,164:44,167:47,171:67,174:59,176:50,178:3,179:83,182:54,183:84,187:74,205:83,207:47,210:34,214:34,216:63,217:86,219:71,221:39,222:55,224:10,225:19,231:72,235:42,236:22,239:47,242:10,243:39,245:61,246:86,251:66,253:82,260:65,261:39,264:1,266:30,275:34,276:71,284:95,286:40,288:78,290:60,296:82,297:50,301:43,302:79,304:98,318:55,320:3,322:42,323:7,324:51,330:62,331:44,335:47,339:74,341:21,343:59,346:90,348:96,354:75,355:53,356:72,358:42,359:3,360:5,361:59,366:28,369:66,372:79,382:46,383:9,385:23,388:84,389:42,390:60,391:6,400:24,402:49,403:3,405:39,409:71,410:52,411:25,415:21,416:83,422:74,423:66,427:5,430:98,435:100,436:88,437:52,444:86,448:48,450:61,452:44,453:76,457:24,459:59,465:45,469:78,472:19,473:42,480:37,484:65,485:85,487:92,488:44,501:21,502:81,504:69,505:26,507:90,510:79,512:71,513:55,516:8,517:12,518:41,521:69,523:74,526:22,528:61,532:62,533:69,536:8,537:79,540:73,542:27,544:83,546:8,548:47,554:36,557:40,561:2,562:43,563:6,565:35,568:80,569:4,570:24,577:44,579:60,580:44,581:84,582:67,583:69,584:53,585:89,586:2,588:95,589:87,590:72,593:84,595:64,596:20,597:14,599:42.\n\nCount 管理 entries: roughly let's count them: I'll count list length. Groups of 10:\n83,72,40,94,61,60,100,95,57,25 →10\n18,93,25,99,58,87,31,70,80,80 →20\n10,29,78,8,93,57,34,66,33,32 →30\n64,100,65,64,16,69,83,98,98,22 →40\n70,7,27,79,55,77,78,3,55,80 →50\n21,88,50,7,83,70,87,44,47,67 →60\n59,50,3,83,54,84,74,83,47,34 →70\n34,63,86,71,39,55,10,19,72,42 →80\n22,47,10,39,61,86,66,82,65,39 →90\n1,30,34,71,95,40,78,60,82,50 →100\n43,79,98,55,3,42,7,51,62,44 →110\n47,74,21,59,90,96,75,53,72,42 →120\n3,5,59,28,66,79,46,9,23,84 →130\n42,60,6,24,49,3,39,71,52,25 →140\n21,83,74,66,5,98,100,88,52,86 →150\n48,61,44,76,24,59,45,78,19,42 →160\n37,65,85,92,44,21,81,69,26,90 →170\n79,71,55,8,12,41,69,74,22,61 →180\n62,69,8,79,73,27,83,8,47,36 →190\n40,2,43,6,35,80,4,24,44,60 →200\n44,84,67,69,53,89,2,95,87,72 →210\n84,64,20,14,42 →215\n\nSum per group:\nG1:83+72=155,+40=195,+94=289,+61=350,+60=410,+100=510,+95=605,+57=662,+25=687\nG2:687+18=705,+93=798,+25=823,+99=922,+58=980,+87=1067,+31=1098,+70=1168,+80=1248,+80=1328\nG3:+10=1338,+29=1367,+78=1445,+8=1453,+93=1546,+57=1603,+34=1637,+66=1703,+33=1736,+32=1768\nG4:+64=1832,+100=1932,+65=1997,+64=2061,+16=2077,+69=2146,+83=2229,+98=2327,+98=2425,+22=2447\nG5:+70=2517,+7=2524,+27=2551,+79=2630,+55=2685,+77=2762,+78=2840,+3=2843,+55=2898,+80=2978\nG6:+21=2999,+88=3087,+50=3137,+7=3144,+83=3227,+70=3297,+87=3384,+44=3428,+47=3475,+67=3542\nG7:+59=3601,+50=3651,+3=3654,+83=3737,+54=3791,+84=3875,+74=3949,+83=4032,+47=4079,+34=4113\nG8:+34=4147,+63=4210,+86=4296,+71=4367,+39=4406,+55=4461,+10=4471,+19=4490,+72=4562,+42=4604\nG9:+22=4626,+47=4673,+10=4683,+39=4722,+61=4783,+86=4869,+66=4935,+82=5017,+65=5082,+39=5121\nG10:+1=5122,+30=5152,+34=5186,+71=5257,+95=5352,+40=5392,+78=5470,+60=5530,+82=5612,+50=5662\nG11:+43=5705,+79=5784,+98=5882,+55=5937,+3=5940,+42=5982,+7=5989,+51=6040,+62=6102,+44=6146\nG12:+47=6193,+74=6267,+21=6288,+59=6347,+90=6437,+96=6533,+75=6608,+53=6661,+72=6733,+42=6775\nG13:+3=6778,+5=6783,+59=6842,+28=6870,+66=6936,+79=7015,+46=7061,+9=7070,+23=7093,+84=7177\nG14:+42=7219,+60=7279,+6=7285,+24=7309,+49=7358,+3=7361,+39=7400,+71=7471,+52=7523,+25=7548\nG15:+21=7569,+83=7652,+74=7726,+66=7792,+5=7797,+98=7895,+100=7995,+88=8083,+52=8135,+86=8221\nG16:+48=8269,+61=8330,+44=8374,+76=8450,+24=8474,+59=8533,+45=8578,+78=8656,+19=8675,+42=8717\nG17:+37=8754,+65=8819,+85=8904,+92=8996,+44=9040,+21=9061,+81=9142,+69=9211,+26=9237,+90=9327\nG18:+79=9406,+71=9477,+55=9532,+8=9540,+12=9552,+41=9593,+69=9662,+74=9736,+22=9758,+61=9819\nG19:+62=9881,+69=9950,+8=9958,+79=10037,+73=10110,+27=10137,+83=10220,+8=10228,+47=10275,+36=10311\nG20:+40=10351,+2=10353,+43=10396,+6=10402,+35=10437,+80=10517,+4=10521,+24=10545,+44=10589,+60=10649\nG21:+44=10693,+84=10777,+67=10844,+69=10913,+53=10966,+89=11055,+2=11057,+95=11152,+87=11239,+72=11311\nG22:+84=11395,+64=11459,+20=11479,+14=11493,+42=11535\n\n合計 11535.{\"answer\":{\"行数\":600,\"最小待ち秒\":1,\"最大待ち秒\":80,\"対象部署の件数合計\":11535,\"指定IDの待ち秒\":71,\"遅延原因\":\"不明\"}}" } }, { "task": "long-records-015", "seed": 289116, "max_generation": 8192, "review": { "category": "wrong_column_copy", "finding_ja": "対象215行のIDは両方一度ずつ列挙。ありは38行で件数ではなく同じ行の待ち秒を転記し、そのリストの合計11535を回答。なしの11482が正解。両上限とも自然終了。", "review_receipt": "output-cap-discordant-case015-r2-mechanism-review.json", "review_receipt_sha256": "33f8ea1aa773156e69cd6c20f7264d1f4949581facd748f0149d63bc88616ac6", "evidence_strength": "emitted_list_reconciled_against_all_target_source_rows" }, "off": { "case": "main-long-records-015-cap8192-sampling-r2-mtp0", "phase": "main", "max_generation": 8192, "task": "long-records-015", "category": "grounded_long_records", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 289116, "rep": 2, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 32768, "generated_tokens": 3705, "first_generated_seconds": 11.084528874023817, "first_visible_seconds": 11.084528874023817, "first_answer_seconds": 85.42091396695469, "end_to_end_seconds": 86.40231840591878, "generation_tps": 49.16640105614594, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "dd8a06b8f77f009c8c4fe9956e66e7ac0b12cb14c1f5aa7dd6a9832456c35afa", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":{\"行数\":600,\"最小待ち秒\":1,\"最大待ち秒\":80,\"対象部署の件数合計\":11482,\"指定IDの待ち秒\":71,\"遅延原因\":\"不明\"}}", "parsed": { "answer": { "行数": 600, "最小待ち秒": 1, "最大待ち秒": 80, "対象部署の件数合計": 11482, "指定IDの待ち秒": 71, "遅延原因": "不明" } }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true }, "complete_token_sequence_sha256": "be70e6aff32bd50477fc1a6282788e5f321ef0a31c528cf37d4545ffce87f9e2", "input_target": 32768, "full_completion": "Count lines: 600. Min wait: 1, max: 80. 管理件数合計: need count. ID512: 71秒. That's heavy—need sum of 管理 counts. Let me count 管理 entries and sums.\n\n管理 ids: 1,9,11,17,20,23,30,35,36,37,38,40,43,44,45,47,52,54,55,60,61,66,69,74,79,80,82,83,84,87,91,94,97,98,109,110,116,117,120,126,127,130,131,132,133,136,140,141,143,145,146,150,153,156,160,161,163,164,167,171,174,176,178,179,182,183,187,205,207,210,214,216,217,219,221,222,224,225,231,235,236,239,242,243,245,246,251,253,260,261,264,266,275,276,284,286,288,290,296,297,301,302,304,318,320,322,323,324,330,331,335,339,341,343,346,348,354,355,356,358,359,360,361,366,369,372,382,383,385,388,389,390,391,400,402,403,405,409,410,411,415,416,422,423,427,430,435,436,437,444,448,450,452,453,457,459,465,469,472,473,480,484,485,487,488,501,502,504,505,507,510,512,513,516,517,518,521,523,526,528,532,533,536,537,540,542,544,546,548,554,557,561,562,563,565,568,569,570,577,579,580,581,582,583,584,585,586,588,589,590,593,595,596,597,599.\n\nCount them: let me count in groups.\nGroup 1-100: ids 1,9,11,17,20,23,30,35,36,37,38,40,43,44,45,47,52,54,55,60,61,66,69,74,79,80,82,83,84,87,91,94,97,98 → 34.\n101-200: 109,110,116,117,120,126,127,130,131,132,133,136,140,141,143,145,146,150,153,156,160,161,163,164,167,171,174,176,178,179,182,183,187 → 33.\n201-300: 205,207,210,214,216,217,219,221,222,224,225,231,235,236,239,242,243,245,246,251,253,260,261,264,266,275,276,284,286,288,290,296,297 → 33.\n301-400: 301,302,304,318,320,322,323,324,330,331,335,339,341,343,346,348,354,355,356,358,359,360,361,366,369,372,382,383,385,388,389,390,391,400 → 34.\n401-500: 402,403,405,409,410,411,415,416,422,423,427,430,435,436,437,444,448,450,452,453,457,459,465,469,472,473,480,484,485,487,488 → 31.\n501-600: 501,502,504,505,507,510,512,513,516,517,518,521,523,526,528,532,533,536,537,540,542,544,546,548,554,557,561,562,563,565,568,569,570,577,579,580,581,582,583,584,585,586,588,589,590,593,595,596,597,599 → 50.\nTotal = 34+33+33+34+31+50 = 215.\n\nNow sum counts for each 管理 line.\n\n1-100 group:\n1:83\n9:72\n11:40\n17:94\n20:61\n23:60\n30:100\n35:95\n36:57\n37:25\n38:18\n40:93\n43:25\n44:99\n45:58\n47:87\n52:31\n54:70\n55:80\n60:80\n61:10\n66:29\n69:78\n74:8\n79:93\n80:57\n82:34\n83:66\n84:37\n87:43\n91:69\n94:100\n97:65\n98:64\n\nSum: 83+72=155; +40=195; +94=289; +61=350; +60=410; +100=510; +95=605; +57=662; +25=687; +18=705; +93=798; +25=823; +99=922; +58=980; +87=1067; +31=1098; +70=1168; +80=1248; +80=1328; +10=1338; +29=1367; +78=1445; +8=1453; +93=1546; +57=1603; +34=1637; +66=1703; +37=1740; +43=1783; +69=1852; +100=1952; +65=2017; +64=2081.\n\n101-200:\n109:16\n110:69\n116:83\n117:98\n120:98\n126:22\n127:70\n130:7\n131:27\n132:79\n133:60\n136:77\n140:6\n141:3\n143:42\n145:80\n146:21\n150:88\n153:50\n156:7\n160:83\n161:70\n163:87\n164:44\n167:47\n171:21\n174:19\n176:50\n178:18\n179:83\n182:54\n183:84\n187:74\n\nSum: 16+69=85;+83=168;+98=266;+98=364;+22=386;+70=456;+7=463;+27=490;+79=569;+60=629;+77=706;+6=712;+3=715;+42=757;+80=837;+21=858;+88=946;+50=996;+7=1003;+83=1086;+70=1156;+87=1243;+44=1287;+47=1334;+21=1355;+19=1374;+50=1424;+18=1442;+83=1525;+54=1579;+84=1663;+74=1737.\n\nRunning total: 2081+1737=3818.\n\n201-300:\n205:83\n207:48\n210:22\n214:34\n216:63\n217:86\n219:71\n221:31\n222:55\n224:74\n225:16\n231:38\n235:42\n236:22\n239:40\n242:12\n243:39\n245:34\n246:86\n251:66\n253:82\n260:41\n261:53\n264:1\n266:32\n275:34\n276:71\n284:95\n286:40\n288:78\n290:60\n296:82\n297:50\n\nSum: 83+48=131;+22=153;+34=187;+63=250;+86=336;+71=407;+31=438;+55=493;+74=567;+16=583;+38=621;+42=663;+22=685;+40=725;+12=737;+39=776;+34=810;+86=896;+66=962;+82=1044;+41=1085;+53=1138;+1=1139;+32=1171;+34=1205;+71=1276;+95=1371;+40=1411;+78=1489;+60=1549;+82=1631;+50=1681.\n\nTotal: 3818+1681=5499.\n\n301-400:\n301:51\n302:48\n304:98\n318:55\n320:3\n322:42\n323:7\n324:51\n330:62\n331:44\n335:47\n339:74\n341:21\n343:59\n346:90\n348:96\n354:75\n355:53\n356:72\n358:33\n359:3\n360:5\n361:59\n366:28\n369:66\n372:79\n382:46\n383:9\n385:23\n388:84\n389:42\n390:60\n391:6\n400:24\n\nSum: 51+48=99;+98=197;+55=252;+3=255;+42=297;+7=304;+51=355;+62=417;+44=461;+47=508;+74=582;+21=603;+59=662;+90=752;+96=848;+75=923;+53=976;+72=1048;+33=1081;+3=1084;+5=1089;+59=1148;+28=1176;+66=1242;+79=1321;+46=1367;+9=1376;+23=1399;+84=1483;+42=1525;+60=1585;+6=1591;+24=1615.\n\nTotal: 5499+1615=7114.\n\n401-500:\n402:49\n403:3\n405:39\n409:71\n410:52\n411:25\n415:21\n416:83\n422:74\n423:66\n427:5\n430:98\n435:100\n436:88\n437:52\n444:86\n448:48\n450:61\n452:44\n453:76\n457:24\n459:59\n465:45\n469:78\n472:19\n473:42\n480:37\n484:65\n485:85\n487:92\n488:44\n\nSum: 49+3=52;+39=91;+71=162;+52=214;+25=239;+21=260;+83=343;+74=417;+66=483;+5=488;+98=586;+100=686;+88=774;+52=826;+86=912;+48=960;+61=1021;+44=1065;+76=1141;+24=1165;+59=1224;+45=1269;+78=1347;+19=1366;+42=1408;+37=1445;+65=1510;+85=1595;+92=1687;+44=1731.\n\nTotal: 7114+1731=8845.\n\n501-600:\n501:21\n502:81\n504:69\n505:26\n507:90\n510:80\n512:84\n513:20\n516:8\n517:37\n518:41\n521:66\n523:74\n526:22\n528:43\n532:62\n533:69\n536:8\n537:79\n540:58\n542:58\n544:83\n546:8\n548:47\n554:36\n557:40\n561:63\n562:43\n563:6\n565:35\n568:80\n569:4\n570:24\n577:44\n579:60\n580:44\n581:84\n582:67\n583:77\n584:71\n585:89\n586:66\n588:95\n589:87\n590:34\n593:84\n595:64\n596:20\n597:44\n599:42\n\nSum: 21+81=102;+69=171;+26=197;+90=287;+80=367;+84=451;+20=471;+8=479;+37=516;+41=557;+66=623;+74=697;+22=719;+43=762;+62=824;+69=893;+8=901;+79=980;+58=1038;+58=1096;+83=1179;+8=1187;+47=1234;+36=1270;+40=1310;+63=1373;+43=1416;+6=1422;+35=1457;+80=1537;+4=1541;+24=1565;+44=1609;+60=1669;+44=1713;+84=1797;+67=1864;+77=1941;+71=2012;+89=2101;+66=2167;+95=2262;+87=2349;+34=2383;+84=2467;+64=2531;+20=2551;+44=2595;+42=2637.\n\nTotal: 8845+2637=11482.\n\nAnswer: {\"行数\":600,\"最小待ち秒\":1,\"最大待ち秒\":80,\"対象部署の件数合計\":11482,\"指定IDの待ち秒\":71,\"遅延原因\":\"不明\"}{\"answer\":{\"行数\":600,\"最小待ち秒\":1,\"最大待ち秒\":80,\"対象部署の件数合計\":11482,\"指定IDの待ち秒\":71,\"遅延原因\":\"不明\"}}" }, "on": { "case": "main-long-records-015-cap8192-sampling-r2-mtp1", "phase": "main", "max_generation": 8192, "task": "long-records-015", "category": "grounded_long_records", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 289116, "rep": 2, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 32768, "generated_tokens": 2887, "first_generated_seconds": 11.42075869999826, "first_visible_seconds": 11.42075869999826, "first_answer_seconds": 45.21649359294679, "end_to_end_seconds": 45.693056011921726, "generation_tps": 84.16687832104591, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 1940, "rejected_draft_tokens": 901, "output_sha256": "6c24bb6968f61c3e518c0968ed5e8c9daecf841c5c7f21a08fc806305e32184e", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":{\"行数\":600,\"最小待ち秒\":1,\"最大待ち秒\":80,\"対象部署の件数合計\":11535,\"指定IDの待ち秒\":71,\"遅延原因\":\"不明\"}}", "parsed": { "answer": { "行数": 600, "最小待ち秒": 1, "最大待ち秒": 80, "対象部署の件数合計": 11535, "指定IDの待ち秒": 71, "遅延原因": "不明" } }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false }, "complete_token_sequence_sha256": "73d32dfc9ea8f28ffb623ea3f7c55a71077835944c95c640943c4f65ad7e4f45", "input_target": 32768, "full_completion": "Count lines: 600. Min wait: 1, max: 80. 管理件数合計 — need to sum 管理件数. ID512: 71. 遅延原因: 不明.\n\nSum 管理件数: let's list 管理 ids and 件数:\n1:83,9:72,11:40,17:94,20:61,23:60,30:100,35:95,36:57,37:25,38:18,40:93,43:25,44:99,45:58,47:87,52:31,54:70,55:80,60:80,61:10,66:29,69:78,74:8,79:93,80:57,82:34,83:66,84:33,87:32,91:64,94:100,97:65,98:64,109:16,110:69,116:83,117:98,120:98,126:22,127:70,130:7,131:27,132:79,133:55,136:77,140:78,141:3,143:55,145:80,146:21,150:88,153:50,156:7,160:83,161:70,163:87,164:44,167:47,171:67,174:59,176:50,178:3,179:83,182:54,183:84,187:74,205:83,207:47,210:34,214:34,216:63,217:86,219:71,221:39,222:55,224:10,225:19,231:72,235:42,236:22,239:47,242:10,243:39,245:61,246:86,251:66,253:82,260:65,261:39,264:1,266:30,275:34,276:71,284:95,286:40,288:78,290:60,296:82,297:50,301:43,302:79,304:98,318:55,320:3,322:42,323:7,324:51,330:62,331:44,335:47,339:74,341:21,343:59,346:90,348:96,354:75,355:53,356:72,358:42,359:3,360:5,361:59,366:28,369:66,372:79,382:46,383:9,385:23,388:84,389:42,390:60,391:6,400:24,402:49,403:3,405:39,409:71,410:52,411:25,415:21,416:83,422:74,423:66,427:5,430:98,435:100,436:88,437:52,444:86,448:48,450:61,452:44,453:76,457:24,459:59,465:45,469:78,472:19,473:42,480:37,484:65,485:85,487:92,488:44,501:21,502:81,504:69,505:26,507:90,510:79,512:71,513:55,516:8,517:12,518:41,521:69,523:74,526:22,528:61,532:62,533:69,536:8,537:79,540:73,542:27,544:83,546:8,548:47,554:36,557:40,561:2,562:43,563:6,565:35,568:80,569:4,570:24,577:44,579:60,580:44,581:84,582:67,583:69,584:53,585:89,586:2,588:95,589:87,590:72,593:84,595:64,596:20,597:14,599:42.\n\nCount 管理 entries: roughly let's count them: I'll count list length. Groups of 10:\n83,72,40,94,61,60,100,95,57,25 →10\n18,93,25,99,58,87,31,70,80,80 →20\n10,29,78,8,93,57,34,66,33,32 →30\n64,100,65,64,16,69,83,98,98,22 →40\n70,7,27,79,55,77,78,3,55,80 →50\n21,88,50,7,83,70,87,44,47,67 →60\n59,50,3,83,54,84,74,83,47,34 →70\n34,63,86,71,39,55,10,19,72,42 →80\n22,47,10,39,61,86,66,82,65,39 →90\n1,30,34,71,95,40,78,60,82,50 →100\n43,79,98,55,3,42,7,51,62,44 →110\n47,74,21,59,90,96,75,53,72,42 →120\n3,5,59,28,66,79,46,9,23,84 →130\n42,60,6,24,49,3,39,71,52,25 →140\n21,83,74,66,5,98,100,88,52,86 →150\n48,61,44,76,24,59,45,78,19,42 →160\n37,65,85,92,44,21,81,69,26,90 →170\n79,71,55,8,12,41,69,74,22,61 →180\n62,69,8,79,73,27,83,8,47,36 →190\n40,2,43,6,35,80,4,24,44,60 →200\n44,84,67,69,53,89,2,95,87,72 →210\n84,64,20,14,42 →215\n\nSum per group:\nG1:83+72=155,+40=195,+94=289,+61=350,+60=410,+100=510,+95=605,+57=662,+25=687\nG2:687+18=705,+93=798,+25=823,+99=922,+58=980,+87=1067,+31=1098,+70=1168,+80=1248,+80=1328\nG3:+10=1338,+29=1367,+78=1445,+8=1453,+93=1546,+57=1603,+34=1637,+66=1703,+33=1736,+32=1768\nG4:+64=1832,+100=1932,+65=1997,+64=2061,+16=2077,+69=2146,+83=2229,+98=2327,+98=2425,+22=2447\nG5:+70=2517,+7=2524,+27=2551,+79=2630,+55=2685,+77=2762,+78=2840,+3=2843,+55=2898,+80=2978\nG6:+21=2999,+88=3087,+50=3137,+7=3144,+83=3227,+70=3297,+87=3384,+44=3428,+47=3475,+67=3542\nG7:+59=3601,+50=3651,+3=3654,+83=3737,+54=3791,+84=3875,+74=3949,+83=4032,+47=4079,+34=4113\nG8:+34=4147,+63=4210,+86=4296,+71=4367,+39=4406,+55=4461,+10=4471,+19=4490,+72=4562,+42=4604\nG9:+22=4626,+47=4673,+10=4683,+39=4722,+61=4783,+86=4869,+66=4935,+82=5017,+65=5082,+39=5121\nG10:+1=5122,+30=5152,+34=5186,+71=5257,+95=5352,+40=5392,+78=5470,+60=5530,+82=5612,+50=5662\nG11:+43=5705,+79=5784,+98=5882,+55=5937,+3=5940,+42=5982,+7=5989,+51=6040,+62=6102,+44=6146\nG12:+47=6193,+74=6267,+21=6288,+59=6347,+90=6437,+96=6533,+75=6608,+53=6661,+72=6733,+42=6775\nG13:+3=6778,+5=6783,+59=6842,+28=6870,+66=6936,+79=7015,+46=7061,+9=7070,+23=7093,+84=7177\nG14:+42=7219,+60=7279,+6=7285,+24=7309,+49=7358,+3=7361,+39=7400,+71=7471,+52=7523,+25=7548\nG15:+21=7569,+83=7652,+74=7726,+66=7792,+5=7797,+98=7895,+100=7995,+88=8083,+52=8135,+86=8221\nG16:+48=8269,+61=8330,+44=8374,+76=8450,+24=8474,+59=8533,+45=8578,+78=8656,+19=8675,+42=8717\nG17:+37=8754,+65=8819,+85=8904,+92=8996,+44=9040,+21=9061,+81=9142,+69=9211,+26=9237,+90=9327\nG18:+79=9406,+71=9477,+55=9532,+8=9540,+12=9552,+41=9593,+69=9662,+74=9736,+22=9758,+61=9819\nG19:+62=9881,+69=9950,+8=9958,+79=10037,+73=10110,+27=10137,+83=10220,+8=10228,+47=10275,+36=10311\nG20:+40=10351,+2=10353,+43=10396,+6=10402,+35=10437,+80=10517,+4=10521,+24=10545,+44=10589,+60=10649\nG21:+44=10693,+84=10777,+67=10844,+69=10913,+53=10966,+89=11055,+2=11057,+95=11152,+87=11239,+72=11311\nG22:+84=11395,+64=11459,+20=11479,+14=11493,+42=11535\n\n合計 11535.{\"answer\":{\"行数\":600,\"最小待ち秒\":1,\"最大待ち秒\":80,\"対象部署の件数合計\":11535,\"指定IDの待ち秒\":71,\"遅延原因\":\"不明\"}}" } } ], "prior600_review_sha256": "1dc076be28cee27346d9bcf5d634ccf6f5d75ee598eae8a90cd82913deebe945", "limits": [ "The generated reasoning is observable text, not a direct measurement of hidden computation.", "No causal attribution to quantization, kernel arithmetic, RNG, draft acceptance or cache handling is established.", "The same task and seed under two caps are not independent tasks." ] }, "followup_case015_source_alignment": { "utc": "2026-10-31T05:24:31.546895+00:00", "reviewer": "Codex", "human_review_claimed": false, "source_evidence_sha256": "4dad91001d66d9698a3bb951a77543cb8f1cd38c8f02d24242145fff7fcca64b", "task_file_sha256": "307a64e5621e9b433a0ec65bbf38324e25b79ebc73993609aa7f8b055aea0ea2", "task": "long-records-015", "seed": 289116, "caps": [ 4096, 8192 ], "same_output_at_both_caps_verified": true, "comparisons": { "False": { "case": "main-long-records-015-cap4096-sampling-r2-mtp0", "source_output_sha256": "dd8a06b8f77f009c8c4fe9956e66e7ac0b12cb14c1f5aa7dd6a9832456c35afa", "all215_target_ids_present_once": true, "listed_pairs": [ [ 1, 83 ], [ 9, 72 ], [ 11, 40 ], [ 17, 94 ], [ 20, 61 ], [ 23, 60 ], [ 30, 100 ], [ 35, 95 ], [ 36, 57 ], [ 37, 25 ], [ 38, 18 ], [ 40, 93 ], [ 43, 25 ], [ 44, 99 ], [ 45, 58 ], [ 47, 87 ], [ 52, 31 ], [ 54, 70 ], [ 55, 80 ], [ 60, 80 ], [ 61, 10 ], [ 66, 29 ], [ 69, 78 ], [ 74, 8 ], [ 79, 93 ], [ 80, 57 ], [ 82, 34 ], [ 83, 66 ], [ 84, 37 ], [ 87, 43 ], [ 91, 69 ], [ 94, 100 ], [ 97, 65 ], [ 98, 64 ], [ 109, 16 ], [ 110, 69 ], [ 116, 83 ], [ 117, 98 ], [ 120, 98 ], [ 126, 22 ], [ 127, 70 ], [ 130, 7 ], [ 131, 27 ], [ 132, 79 ], [ 133, 60 ], [ 136, 77 ], [ 140, 6 ], [ 141, 3 ], [ 143, 42 ], [ 145, 80 ], [ 146, 21 ], [ 150, 88 ], [ 153, 50 ], [ 156, 7 ], [ 160, 83 ], [ 161, 70 ], [ 163, 87 ], [ 164, 44 ], [ 167, 47 ], [ 171, 21 ], [ 174, 19 ], [ 176, 50 ], [ 178, 18 ], [ 179, 83 ], [ 182, 54 ], [ 183, 84 ], [ 187, 74 ], [ 205, 83 ], [ 207, 48 ], [ 210, 22 ], [ 214, 34 ], [ 216, 63 ], [ 217, 86 ], [ 219, 71 ], [ 221, 31 ], [ 222, 55 ], [ 224, 74 ], [ 225, 16 ], [ 231, 38 ], [ 235, 42 ], [ 236, 22 ], [ 239, 40 ], [ 242, 12 ], [ 243, 39 ], [ 245, 34 ], [ 246, 86 ], [ 251, 66 ], [ 253, 82 ], [ 260, 41 ], [ 261, 53 ], [ 264, 1 ], [ 266, 32 ], [ 275, 34 ], [ 276, 71 ], [ 284, 95 ], [ 286, 40 ], [ 288, 78 ], [ 290, 60 ], [ 296, 82 ], [ 297, 50 ], [ 301, 51 ], [ 302, 48 ], [ 304, 98 ], [ 318, 55 ], [ 320, 3 ], [ 322, 42 ], [ 323, 7 ], [ 324, 51 ], [ 330, 62 ], [ 331, 44 ], [ 335, 47 ], [ 339, 74 ], [ 341, 21 ], [ 343, 59 ], [ 346, 90 ], [ 348, 96 ], [ 354, 75 ], [ 355, 53 ], [ 356, 72 ], [ 358, 33 ], [ 359, 3 ], [ 360, 5 ], [ 361, 59 ], [ 366, 28 ], [ 369, 66 ], [ 372, 79 ], [ 382, 46 ], [ 383, 9 ], [ 385, 23 ], [ 388, 84 ], [ 389, 42 ], [ 390, 60 ], [ 391, 6 ], [ 400, 24 ], [ 402, 49 ], [ 403, 3 ], [ 405, 39 ], [ 409, 71 ], [ 410, 52 ], [ 411, 25 ], [ 415, 21 ], [ 416, 83 ], [ 422, 74 ], [ 423, 66 ], [ 427, 5 ], [ 430, 98 ], [ 435, 100 ], [ 436, 88 ], [ 437, 52 ], [ 444, 86 ], [ 448, 48 ], [ 450, 61 ], [ 452, 44 ], [ 453, 76 ], [ 457, 24 ], [ 459, 59 ], [ 465, 45 ], [ 469, 78 ], [ 472, 19 ], [ 473, 42 ], [ 480, 37 ], [ 484, 65 ], [ 485, 85 ], [ 487, 92 ], [ 488, 44 ], [ 501, 21 ], [ 502, 81 ], [ 504, 69 ], [ 505, 26 ], [ 507, 90 ], [ 510, 80 ], [ 512, 84 ], [ 513, 20 ], [ 516, 8 ], [ 517, 37 ], [ 518, 41 ], [ 521, 66 ], [ 523, 74 ], [ 526, 22 ], [ 528, 43 ], [ 532, 62 ], [ 533, 69 ], [ 536, 8 ], [ 537, 79 ], [ 540, 58 ], [ 542, 58 ], [ 544, 83 ], [ 546, 8 ], [ 548, 47 ], [ 554, 36 ], [ 557, 40 ], [ 561, 63 ], [ 562, 43 ], [ 563, 6 ], [ 565, 35 ], [ 568, 80 ], [ 569, 4 ], [ 570, 24 ], [ 577, 44 ], [ 579, 60 ], [ 580, 44 ], [ 581, 84 ], [ 582, 67 ], [ 583, 77 ], [ 584, 71 ], [ 585, 89 ], [ 586, 66 ], [ 588, 95 ], [ 589, 87 ], [ 590, 34 ], [ 593, 84 ], [ 595, 64 ], [ 596, 20 ], [ 597, 44 ], [ 599, 42 ] ], "wrong_source_values": [], "wrong_values_count": 0, "all_wrong_values_equal_same_row_wait_column": true, "sum_of_listed_values": 11482, "reported_answer": 11482, "reported_sum_equals_listed_value_sum": true, "expected_sum": 11482, "sum_difference": 0 }, "True": { "case": "main-long-records-015-cap4096-sampling-r2-mtp1", "source_output_sha256": "6c24bb6968f61c3e518c0968ed5e8c9daecf841c5c7f21a08fc806305e32184e", "all215_target_ids_present_once": true, "listed_pairs": [ [ 1, 83 ], [ 9, 72 ], [ 11, 40 ], [ 17, 94 ], [ 20, 61 ], [ 23, 60 ], [ 30, 100 ], [ 35, 95 ], [ 36, 57 ], [ 37, 25 ], [ 38, 18 ], [ 40, 93 ], [ 43, 25 ], [ 44, 99 ], [ 45, 58 ], [ 47, 87 ], [ 52, 31 ], [ 54, 70 ], [ 55, 80 ], [ 60, 80 ], [ 61, 10 ], [ 66, 29 ], [ 69, 78 ], [ 74, 8 ], [ 79, 93 ], [ 80, 57 ], [ 82, 34 ], [ 83, 66 ], [ 84, 33 ], [ 87, 32 ], [ 91, 64 ], [ 94, 100 ], [ 97, 65 ], [ 98, 64 ], [ 109, 16 ], [ 110, 69 ], [ 116, 83 ], [ 117, 98 ], [ 120, 98 ], [ 126, 22 ], [ 127, 70 ], [ 130, 7 ], [ 131, 27 ], [ 132, 79 ], [ 133, 55 ], [ 136, 77 ], [ 140, 78 ], [ 141, 3 ], [ 143, 55 ], [ 145, 80 ], [ 146, 21 ], [ 150, 88 ], [ 153, 50 ], [ 156, 7 ], [ 160, 83 ], [ 161, 70 ], [ 163, 87 ], [ 164, 44 ], [ 167, 47 ], [ 171, 67 ], [ 174, 59 ], [ 176, 50 ], [ 178, 3 ], [ 179, 83 ], [ 182, 54 ], [ 183, 84 ], [ 187, 74 ], [ 205, 83 ], [ 207, 47 ], [ 210, 34 ], [ 214, 34 ], [ 216, 63 ], [ 217, 86 ], [ 219, 71 ], [ 221, 39 ], [ 222, 55 ], [ 224, 10 ], [ 225, 19 ], [ 231, 72 ], [ 235, 42 ], [ 236, 22 ], [ 239, 47 ], [ 242, 10 ], [ 243, 39 ], [ 245, 61 ], [ 246, 86 ], [ 251, 66 ], [ 253, 82 ], [ 260, 65 ], [ 261, 39 ], [ 264, 1 ], [ 266, 30 ], [ 275, 34 ], [ 276, 71 ], [ 284, 95 ], [ 286, 40 ], [ 288, 78 ], [ 290, 60 ], [ 296, 82 ], [ 297, 50 ], [ 301, 43 ], [ 302, 79 ], [ 304, 98 ], [ 318, 55 ], [ 320, 3 ], [ 322, 42 ], [ 323, 7 ], [ 324, 51 ], [ 330, 62 ], [ 331, 44 ], [ 335, 47 ], [ 339, 74 ], [ 341, 21 ], [ 343, 59 ], [ 346, 90 ], [ 348, 96 ], [ 354, 75 ], [ 355, 53 ], [ 356, 72 ], [ 358, 42 ], [ 359, 3 ], [ 360, 5 ], [ 361, 59 ], [ 366, 28 ], [ 369, 66 ], [ 372, 79 ], [ 382, 46 ], [ 383, 9 ], [ 385, 23 ], [ 388, 84 ], [ 389, 42 ], [ 390, 60 ], [ 391, 6 ], [ 400, 24 ], [ 402, 49 ], [ 403, 3 ], [ 405, 39 ], [ 409, 71 ], [ 410, 52 ], [ 411, 25 ], [ 415, 21 ], [ 416, 83 ], [ 422, 74 ], [ 423, 66 ], [ 427, 5 ], [ 430, 98 ], [ 435, 100 ], [ 436, 88 ], [ 437, 52 ], [ 444, 86 ], [ 448, 48 ], [ 450, 61 ], [ 452, 44 ], [ 453, 76 ], [ 457, 24 ], [ 459, 59 ], [ 465, 45 ], [ 469, 78 ], [ 472, 19 ], [ 473, 42 ], [ 480, 37 ], [ 484, 65 ], [ 485, 85 ], [ 487, 92 ], [ 488, 44 ], [ 501, 21 ], [ 502, 81 ], [ 504, 69 ], [ 505, 26 ], [ 507, 90 ], [ 510, 79 ], [ 512, 71 ], [ 513, 55 ], [ 516, 8 ], [ 517, 12 ], [ 518, 41 ], [ 521, 69 ], [ 523, 74 ], [ 526, 22 ], [ 528, 61 ], [ 532, 62 ], [ 533, 69 ], [ 536, 8 ], [ 537, 79 ], [ 540, 73 ], [ 542, 27 ], [ 544, 83 ], [ 546, 8 ], [ 548, 47 ], [ 554, 36 ], [ 557, 40 ], [ 561, 2 ], [ 562, 43 ], [ 563, 6 ], [ 565, 35 ], [ 568, 80 ], [ 569, 4 ], [ 570, 24 ], [ 577, 44 ], [ 579, 60 ], [ 580, 44 ], [ 581, 84 ], [ 582, 67 ], [ 583, 69 ], [ 584, 53 ], [ 585, 89 ], [ 586, 2 ], [ 588, 95 ], [ 589, 87 ], [ 590, 72 ], [ 593, 84 ], [ 595, 64 ], [ 596, 20 ], [ 597, 14 ], [ 599, 42 ] ], "wrong_source_values": [ { "id": 84, "expected_count": 37, "wait_seconds": 33, "copied_value": 33, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -4 }, { "id": 87, "expected_count": 43, "wait_seconds": 32, "copied_value": 32, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -11 }, { "id": 91, "expected_count": 69, "wait_seconds": 64, "copied_value": 64, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -5 }, { "id": 133, "expected_count": 60, "wait_seconds": 55, "copied_value": 55, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -5 }, { "id": 140, "expected_count": 6, "wait_seconds": 78, "copied_value": 78, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 72 }, { "id": 143, "expected_count": 42, "wait_seconds": 55, "copied_value": 55, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 13 }, { "id": 171, "expected_count": 21, "wait_seconds": 67, "copied_value": 67, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 46 }, { "id": 174, "expected_count": 19, "wait_seconds": 59, "copied_value": 59, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 40 }, { "id": 178, "expected_count": 18, "wait_seconds": 3, "copied_value": 3, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -15 }, { "id": 207, "expected_count": 48, "wait_seconds": 47, "copied_value": 47, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -1 }, { "id": 210, "expected_count": 22, "wait_seconds": 34, "copied_value": 34, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 12 }, { "id": 221, "expected_count": 31, "wait_seconds": 39, "copied_value": 39, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 8 }, { "id": 224, "expected_count": 74, "wait_seconds": 10, "copied_value": 10, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -64 }, { "id": 225, "expected_count": 16, "wait_seconds": 19, "copied_value": 19, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 3 }, { "id": 231, "expected_count": 38, "wait_seconds": 72, "copied_value": 72, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 34 }, { "id": 239, "expected_count": 40, "wait_seconds": 47, "copied_value": 47, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 7 }, { "id": 242, "expected_count": 12, "wait_seconds": 10, "copied_value": 10, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -2 }, { "id": 245, "expected_count": 34, "wait_seconds": 61, "copied_value": 61, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 27 }, { "id": 260, "expected_count": 41, "wait_seconds": 65, "copied_value": 65, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 24 }, { "id": 261, "expected_count": 53, "wait_seconds": 39, "copied_value": 39, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -14 }, { "id": 266, "expected_count": 32, "wait_seconds": 30, "copied_value": 30, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -2 }, { "id": 301, "expected_count": 51, "wait_seconds": 43, "copied_value": 43, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -8 }, { "id": 302, "expected_count": 48, "wait_seconds": 79, "copied_value": 79, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 31 }, { "id": 358, "expected_count": 33, "wait_seconds": 42, "copied_value": 42, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 9 }, { "id": 510, "expected_count": 80, "wait_seconds": 79, "copied_value": 79, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -1 }, { "id": 512, "expected_count": 84, "wait_seconds": 71, "copied_value": 71, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -13 }, { "id": 513, "expected_count": 20, "wait_seconds": 55, "copied_value": 55, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 35 }, { "id": 517, "expected_count": 37, "wait_seconds": 12, "copied_value": 12, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -25 }, { "id": 521, "expected_count": 66, "wait_seconds": 69, "copied_value": 69, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 3 }, { "id": 528, "expected_count": 43, "wait_seconds": 61, "copied_value": 61, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 18 }, { "id": 540, "expected_count": 58, "wait_seconds": 73, "copied_value": 73, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 15 }, { "id": 542, "expected_count": 58, "wait_seconds": 27, "copied_value": 27, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -31 }, { "id": 561, "expected_count": 63, "wait_seconds": 2, "copied_value": 2, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -61 }, { "id": 583, "expected_count": 77, "wait_seconds": 69, "copied_value": 69, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -8 }, { "id": 584, "expected_count": 71, "wait_seconds": 53, "copied_value": 53, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -18 }, { "id": 586, "expected_count": 66, "wait_seconds": 2, "copied_value": 2, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -64 }, { "id": 590, "expected_count": 34, "wait_seconds": 72, "copied_value": 72, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": 38 }, { "id": 597, "expected_count": 44, "wait_seconds": 14, "copied_value": 14, "equals_wait_column": true, "difference": -30 } ], "wrong_values_count": 38, "all_wrong_values_equal_same_row_wait_column": true, "sum_of_listed_values": 11535, "reported_answer": 11535, "reported_sum_equals_listed_value_sum": true, "expected_sum": 11482, "sum_difference": 53 } }, "scope": "Directly observed error mechanism in emitted reasoning text; not proof of the hidden causal origin or a general MTP-quality regression. All claims must be reconciled with final collected files.", "conclusions": [ "The off answer lists every target ID once with all source counts correct and sums them to11482.", "The on answer lists every target ID once but substitutes same-row wait_seconds for some count values; the extracted list itself sums to the wrong reported answer11535.", "Neither response was truncated; both naturally stopped below4096. The same completions recurred at8192.", "The visible error is wrong-column copying before addition, rather than insufficient budget or incorrect addition of the emitted list. Why the decoding paths diverged requires separate evidence; emitted reasoning is not a faithful-internal-causality guarantee." ] }, "original600_review": { "utc": "2026-10-31T05:29:41.250859+00:00", "reviewer": "Codex", "human_review_claimed": false, "all_original_off_correct_on_wrong_pairs_read": true, "source_input_sha256": "ac51ba6a09b76d0d7860dc705cca40e7566dadebb3cf2af0642217a7fdc2eb2d", "source_audit_sha256": "95cece7e5a3827a19aa0b6a5fa03aaeb9ddb00436394c55b40003f91fe08cd67", "sampling_pairs": 11, "greedy_pairs_separate": 1, "original_sampling_off_correct_denominator": 1664, "regressions_among_off_passes_percentage": 0.6610576923076923, "sampling_classification": { "clear_content_error": 7, "output_contract": 3, "wording_ambiguity": 1 }, "pairs": [ { "task": "code-008", "mode": "greedy", "rep": 0, "seed": 3571, "expected": [ 18, 12, 11 ], "off_answer": [ 18, 12, 11 ], "on_answer": [ 18, 12, 0 ], "off_output_sha256": "44edb398a82aabb193a47db3648214e4ddd2d12b61c9e8bf5c45aa233cbdf864", "on_output_sha256": "fd91417dd271c0328891d2dbfa019acaccf280f60a3e2771c33e0dde212bba4c", "category": "slice_selection", "label_ja": "スライスの位置違い", "finding_ja": "正しい添字は1,3,5。ありの末尾0は添字6の値。思考文はなく、内部でどの計算をしたかは不明。", "evidence_strength": "final_answer_only", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 }, { "task": "code-056", "mode": "sampling", "rep": 1, "seed": 1144997408, "expected": 10, "off_answer": 10, "on_answer": 13, "off_output_sha256": "7014ecf5584b57f9f1262040edeab8dd01bc939489e8a7feb079bdecc873ed67", "on_output_sha256": "416cfdc4a6d23a800ebe988eac31ad858ecf4c2eea2039c014b0ba2a4b782f95", "category": "index_interpretation", "label_ja": "末尾から2番目の取り違え", "finding_ja": "両方とも昇順リストは正しく列挙。ありは[-2]を最後の値13としている。正解は10。", "evidence_strength": "emitted_steps_show_error", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 }, { "task": "logic-039", "mode": "sampling", "rep": 2, "seed": 1427608789, "expected": 1, "off_answer": 1, "on_answer": 2, "off_output_sha256": "31dfd8660625903f4699650ed7010875db068b3e66f676011f99e092edb085d7", "on_output_sha256": "6de1b659b5791e1538780ee07b5f5c6be971dcc606d56f1c48513c70621648e6", "category": "wording_ambiguity", "label_ja": "設問の「複数」と最小値が曖昧", "finding_ja": "6人は定員6のBだけに入るため元の正解は1。ただし「複数の会議室」を文字どおり読むと2も合理的。明確なMTP品質悪化とは扱わない。既存の20問一括除外感度分析も保持。", "evidence_strength": "ambiguous_question", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 }, { "task": "arithmetic-053", "mode": "sampling", "rep": 2, "seed": 1791303408, "expected": 93.95, "off_answer": 93.95, "on_answer": "93.95%", "off_output_sha256": "078e2015602d4edef674a10063999fcc4954d42a66e51a2704542668c07b21f0", "on_output_sha256": "cc3c1ce21d27eb6666900f8c8d802883e710d9df4b5d933292e3f4425f8ee65e", "category": "output_contract", "label_ja": "数値型・単位の指定違反", "finding_ja": "数値93.95は両方同じ。ありは単位付き文字列93.95%を返し、数値に単位を付けない出力仕様に違反。JSON構文自体は妥当。", "evidence_strength": "direct_output_contract", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 }, { "task": "code-037", "mode": "sampling", "rep": 0, "seed": 501238494, "expected": 228, "off_answer": 228, "on_answer": 113, "off_output_sha256": "c81bd0d630230da9424508ee05b4b82007bf3d712ffb45210fa54459a51dc71b", "on_output_sha256": "589360f95bd9604828bbbb57db7d844b1a2a1322d2d6604297eb134428de38dd", "category": "loop_state", "label_ja": "ループ状態更新の誤り", "finding_ja": "正しい状態は29→58→115→228。ありの出力過程は29→58→57→113で、2回目の更新から異なる。", "evidence_strength": "emitted_steps_show_error", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 }, { "task": "records-012", "mode": "sampling", "rep": 0, "seed": 3204126560, "expected": 542, "off_answer": 542, "on_answer": 442, "off_output_sha256": "e542dda9c47c4b5dca6feade7e667dd970293aa6dbb254ca3cf9a94faf25939f", "on_output_sha256": "8e8dead8064ee5ebcf6a50c8866a280657600643d17d43f4a076c08996d58812", "category": "addition", "label_ja": "正しい加数の合計を誤る", "finding_ja": "両方とも同じ12個の正しい加数を列挙。合計は542だが、ありは442と出力した。", "evidence_strength": "emitted_steps_show_error", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 }, { "task": "arithmetic-018", "mode": "sampling", "rep": 2, "seed": 1902073540, "expected": 89.5, "off_answer": 89.5, "on_answer": "89.50%", "off_output_sha256": "4d6b5ce4ce7798b1f41e32b5a9100717d1e0ddc2cd7e86febc007890d793ed8b", "on_output_sha256": "956b6b09dde0ede9bc3d367731bdbb14a0b27131acaa887d8305f7eb952c49ee", "category": "output_contract", "label_ja": "数値型・単位の指定違反", "finding_ja": "89.5と89.50%は数量として同じだが、ありは単位付き文字列を返す。計算の間違いと区別する。", "evidence_strength": "direct_output_contract", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 }, { "task": "code-054", "mode": "sampling", "rep": 1, "seed": 332336680, "expected": 101, "off_answer": 101, "on_answer": 87, "off_output_sha256": "6cc824f3be5b67feda66dd7454d4502b9d71d3eaea78d1a307bb027f1822cba2", "on_output_sha256": "df2599fd7f7b78a28e7cfea9c213c13b5e32ebeea98459c959b4b767e6c800d5", "category": "weighted_terms", "label_ja": "添字と値の積の取り違え", "finding_ja": "正しい項は0,-5,18,18,4,45,0,21。ありは2項目を-25、4項目を24としている。その誤った項の合計は出力87と一致する。", "evidence_strength": "emitted_steps_show_error", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 }, { "task": "logic-027", "mode": "sampling", "rep": 0, "seed": 3179642043, "expected": "断定できない", "off_answer": "断定できない", "on_answer": "断定できる", "off_output_sha256": "5ecb23cbfd41d73890c3dd1add61e5b195d3d416badcfcbc1523a48da5af338b", "on_output_sha256": "c2942c2ea84287c71f36afc2204ea14610789442b4bdeebc770b446dc3710a9b", "category": "implication", "label_ja": "必要条件から原因を断定", "finding_ja": "障害なら通知という規則と通知の存在だけでは障害を断定できない。ありの断定できるは誤り。思考文がないので内部の誤推論の経路は不明。", "evidence_strength": "final_answer_only", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 }, { "task": "arithmetic-092", "mode": "sampling", "rep": 1, "seed": 4096328267, "expected": 75, "off_answer": 75, "on_answer": 74, "off_output_sha256": "d45a5571ecfb6a7ffe593c58607a5076de3b56c2820916e5a6c5597848b45f44", "on_output_sha256": "7d15928f4cc1066209814e39f636c66ac50e6dfed244c2758a5700f8ab2cfa74", "category": "ceiling", "label_ja": "端数の切り上げを落とす", "finding_ja": "両方とも商74.01…を認識。74箱では5402個しか入らず、残り1個のため75箱必要。ありは74箱と回答した。", "evidence_strength": "emitted_steps_show_error", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 }, { "task": "records-037", "mode": "sampling", "rep": 1, "seed": 4029129600, "expected": 371, "off_answer": 371, "on_answer": 381, "off_output_sha256": "41346347e6945bcf105df86aae0d4f2c4ac50cd47c678bca8c8f0f9bb2658ce2", "on_output_sha256": "93c312662937c44ed6d8614fa9f8baaacccfafece03f2d344b69fa3e9c1b71b1", "category": "addition", "label_ja": "正しい加数と異なる合計を返す", "finding_ja": "両方とも同じ12個の正しい加数を列挙。合計は371だが、ありは381と出力した。", "evidence_strength": "emitted_steps_show_error", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 }, { "task": "arithmetic-058", "mode": "sampling", "rep": 2, "seed": 3730798878, "expected": 87.96, "off_answer": 87.96, "on_answer": "87.96%", "off_output_sha256": "97f618f32248854e705c48229b346be10dc3f397e722464f888d6ecae2af90e9", "on_output_sha256": "474901e99f879599af9a2f29e7aeed796e681f9244f36b15d7eb493706cf2b5b", "category": "output_contract", "label_ja": "数値型・単位の指定違反", "finding_ja": "数値87.96は両方同じ。ありだけ単位付き文字列87.96%を返す出力仕様違反。", "evidence_strength": "direct_output_contract", "natural_stop_both": true, "max_output_tokens": 1024 } ], "original_scores_unchanged": true, "claim_limit": "Observed differences and visible error steps; not a proof that quantization, draft acceptance, RNG handling, KV state or a particular kernel caused the divergence. No missing reasoning is invented." }, "original600_all_off_correct_on_wrong_input_and_completions": { "source_audit_sha256": "95cece7e5a3827a19aa0b6a5fa03aaeb9ddb00436394c55b40003f91fe08cd67", "pairs": [ { "task": { "id": "code-008", "category": "code", "template_variant": 3, "question": "次のPython 3コードのprintが出力する値を答えてください。コードは実行せず読解してください。\n```python\nxs = [2, 18, -4, 12, -3, 11, 0, 8]\nprint(xs[1:7:2])\n```", "expected": [ 18, 12, 11 ], "seeds": [ 838975961, 2032005786, 2392992620 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": true }, "mode": "greedy", "rep": 0, "off": { "full_completion": "{\"answer\":[18, 12, 11]}", "measurement": { "case": "code-008-greedy-r0-mtp0", "task": "code-008", "category": "code", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "greedy", "seed": 3571, "rep": 0, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 13, "first_generated_seconds": 1.520132364006713, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5397590979700908, "first_answer_seconds": 1.5397590979700908, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.7634148229844868, "generation_tps": 45.930034959706454, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "44edb398a82aabb193a47db3648214e4ddd2d12b61c9e8bf5c45aa233cbdf864", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":[18, 12, 11]}", "parsed": { "answer": [ 18, 12, 11 ] }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "{\"answer\":[18, 12, 0]}", "measurement": { "case": "code-008-greedy-r0-mtp1", "task": "code-008", "category": "code", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "greedy", "seed": 3571, "rep": 0, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 13, "first_generated_seconds": 1.574317225953564, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5743390279822052, "first_answer_seconds": 1.5743390279822052, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.680322243948467, "generation_tps": 87.5091027002968, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 9, "rejected_draft_tokens": 3, "output_sha256": "fd91417dd271c0328891d2dbfa019acaccf280f60a3e2771c33e0dde212bba4c", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":[18, 12, 0]}", "parsed": { "answer": [ 18, 12, 0 ] }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } }, { "task": { "id": "code-056", "category": "code", "template_variant": 1, "question": "次のPython 3コードのprintが出力する値を答えてください。コードは実行せず読解してください。\n```python\nxs = [13, -2, 9, 6, 6, -1, 6, 10]\nprint(sorted(set(xs))[-2])\n```", "expected": 10, "seeds": [ 2003929982, 1144997408, 3250736474 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": false }, "mode": "sampling", "rep": 1, "off": { "full_completion": "set sorted: [-2,-1,6,9,10,13] → [-2] = 13-1... [-2] is 10? sorted ascending: -2,-1,6,9,10,13 → second from end = 10.{\"answer\": 10}", "measurement": { "case": "code-056-sampling-r1-mtp0", "task": "code-056", "category": "code", "template_variant": 1, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 1144997408, "rep": 1, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 64, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5198866439750418, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5198866439750418, "first_answer_seconds": 2.6745713209966198, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.798814933979884, "generation_tps": 48.54044100628025, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "7014ecf5584b57f9f1262040edeab8dd01bc939489e8a7feb079bdecc873ed67", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\": 10}", "parsed": { "answer": 10 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "set sorted: [-2,-1,6,9,10,13] → [-2] = 13.{\"answer\": 13}", "measurement": { "case": "code-056-sampling-r1-mtp1", "task": "code-056", "category": "code", "template_variant": 1, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 1144997408, "rep": 1, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 32, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5732371530029923, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5732371530029923, "first_answer_seconds": 1.8832043630536646, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.9203694910975173, "generation_tps": 81.87981327208988, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 21, "rejected_draft_tokens": 12, "output_sha256": "416cfdc4a6d23a800ebe988eac31ad858ecf4c2eea2039c014b0ba2a4b782f95", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\": 13}", "parsed": { "answer": 13 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } }, { "task": { "id": "logic-039", "category": "logic", "template_variant": 4, "question": "会議室A、B、Cの定員は順に[2, 6, 2]人です。6人を複数の会議室に分けて収容します。必要な会議室数の最小値を答えてください。", "expected": 1, "seeds": [ 3615503059, 707316697, 1427608789 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": false }, "mode": "sampling", "rep": 2, "off": { "full_completion": "6 = 2+2+2 → 3 rooms? Or 6 fits room B alone → 1 room.{\"answer\":1}", "measurement": { "case": "logic-039-sampling-r2-mtp0", "task": "logic-039", "category": "logic", "template_variant": 4, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 1427608789, "rep": 2, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 32, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5163445340003818, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5163445340003818, "first_answer_seconds": 2.0325670670717955, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.1658307251054794, "generation_tps": 48.489877324064736, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "31dfd8660625903f4699650ed7010875db068b3e66f676011f99e092edb085d7", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":1}", "parsed": { "answer": 1 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "{\"answer\": 2}", "measurement": { "case": "logic-039-sampling-r2-mtp1", "task": "logic-039", "category": "logic", "template_variant": 4, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 1427608789, "rep": 2, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 8, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5706281830789521, "first_visible_seconds": 1.6047870860202238, "first_answer_seconds": 1.6047870860202238, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.6489418880082667, "generation_tps": 68.2481002889374, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 5, "rejected_draft_tokens": 4, "output_sha256": "6de1b659b5791e1538780ee07b5f5c6be971dcc606d56f1c48513c70621648e6", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\": 2}", "parsed": { "answer": 2 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } }, { "task": { "id": "arithmetic-053", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 3, "question": "売上43000円、仕入原価2600円です。売上に対する粗利率を百分率で小数第2位まで四捨五入して答えてください。", "expected": 93.95, "seeds": [ 2246743948, 3742222525, 1791303408 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": false }, "mode": "sampling", "rep": 2, "off": { "full_completion": "(43000-2600)/43000=40400/43000≈93.953...→93.95{\"answer\":93.95}", "measurement": { "case": "arithmetic-053-sampling-r2-mtp0", "task": "arithmetic-053", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 1791303408, "rep": 2, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 35, "first_generated_seconds": 1.513380861026235, "first_visible_seconds": 1.513380861026235, "first_answer_seconds": 2.0590874379267916, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.2057014940073714, "generation_tps": 47.77831845213167, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "078e2015602d4edef674a10063999fcc4954d42a66e51a2704542668c07b21f0", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":93.95}", "parsed": { "answer": 93.95 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "(43000-2600)/43000 = 40400/43000 = 0.93953... → 93.95%{\"answer\":\"93.95%\"}", "measurement": { "case": "arithmetic-053-sampling-r2-mtp1", "task": "arithmetic-053", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 1791303408, "rep": 2, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 41, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5681938179768622, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5681938179768622, "first_answer_seconds": 1.9081602229271084, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.0128277979092672, "generation_tps": 84.02977090825311, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 27, "rejected_draft_tokens": 15, "output_sha256": "cc3c1ce21d27eb6666900f8c8d802883e710d9df4b5d933292e3f4425f8ee65e", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":\"93.95%\"}", "parsed": { "answer": "93.95%" }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } }, { "task": { "id": "code-037", "category": "code", "template_variant": 2, "question": "次のPython 3コードのprintが出力する値を答えてください。コードは実行せず読解してください。\n```python\nx = 29\nfor i in range(3):\n x = x * 2 - i\nprint(x)\n```", "expected": 228, "seeds": [ 501238494, 1082910436, 2640250205 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": false }, "mode": "sampling", "rep": 0, "off": { "full_completion": "29→58, 58*2-1=115, 115*2-2=228{\"answer\":228}", "measurement": { "case": "code-037-sampling-r0-mtp0", "task": "code-037", "category": "code", "template_variant": 2, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 501238494, "rep": 0, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 28, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5184825040632859, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5184825040632859, "first_answer_seconds": 1.9591967120068148, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.066643900005147, "generation_tps": 48.10948172989222, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "c81bd0d630230da9424508ee05b4b82007bf3d712ffb45210fa54459a51dc71b", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":228}", "parsed": { "answer": 228 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "29→58, 57, 113{\"answer\":113}", "measurement": { "case": "code-037-sampling-r0-mtp1", "task": "code-037", "category": "code", "template_variant": 2, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 501238494, "rep": 0, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 16, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5745121259242296, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5745121259242296, "first_answer_seconds": 1.779503011959605, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.8531677479622886, "generation_tps": 48.70980628977563, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 7, "rejected_draft_tokens": 20, "output_sha256": "589360f95bd9604828bbbb57db7d844b1a2a1322d2d6604297eb134428de38dd", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":113}", "parsed": { "answer": 113 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } }, { "task": { "id": "records-012", "category": "records", "template_variant": 2, "question": "次のJSONだけを根拠に、全行のqtyからreturnedを引いた数の合計を答えてください。\n[{\"id\": \"R01\", \"department\": \"営業\", \"qty\": 95, \"returned\": 2, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R02\", \"department\": \"営業\", \"qty\": 78, \"returned\": 2, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R03\", \"department\": \"開発\", \"qty\": 76, \"returned\": 3, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R04\", \"department\": \"営業\", \"qty\": 2, \"returned\": 2, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R05\", \"department\": \"開発\", \"qty\": 17, \"returned\": 3, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R06\", \"department\": \"管理\", \"qty\": 9, \"returned\": 2, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R07\", \"department\": \"管理\", \"qty\": 55, \"returned\": 3, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R08\", \"department\": \"開発\", \"qty\": 60, \"returned\": 3, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R09\", \"department\": \"開発\", \"qty\": 20, \"returned\": 2, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R10\", \"department\": \"営業\", \"qty\": 73, \"returned\": 3, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R11\", \"department\": \"営業\", \"qty\": 72, \"returned\": 4, \"status\": \"確定\"}, {\"id\": \"R12\", \"department\": \"管理\", \"qty\": 16, \"returned\": 2, \"status\": \"確定\"}]", "expected": 542, "seeds": [ 3204126560, 1840085236, 2175506879 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": true }, "mode": "sampling", "rep": 0, "off": { "full_completion": "qty−returned sum: 93+76+73+0+14+7+52+57+18+70+68+14 = 542.{\"answer\": 542}", "measurement": { "case": "records-012-sampling-r0-mtp0", "task": "records-012", "category": "records", "template_variant": 2, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 3204126560, "rep": 0, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 43, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5604594110045582, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5604594110045582, "first_answer_seconds": 2.277221634052694, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.4204433229751885, "generation_tps": 47.80844139895531, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "e542dda9c47c4b5dca6feade7e667dd970293aa6dbb254ca3cf9a94faf25939f", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\": 542}", "parsed": { "answer": 542 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "qty−returned sum: 93+76+73+0+14+7+52+57+18+70+68+14 = 442.{\"answer\":442}", "measurement": { "case": "records-012-sampling-r0-mtp1", "task": "records-012", "category": "records", "template_variant": 2, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 3204126560, "rep": 0, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 42, "first_generated_seconds": 1.6144412390422076, "first_visible_seconds": 1.6144412390422076, "first_answer_seconds": 2.1270979460095987, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.1961104590445757, "generation_tps": 66.63334246491478, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 24, "rejected_draft_tokens": 30, "output_sha256": "8e8dead8064ee5ebcf6a50c8866a280657600643d17d43f4a076c08996d58812", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":442}", "parsed": { "answer": 442 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } }, { "task": { "id": "arithmetic-018", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 3, "question": "売上80000円、仕入原価8400円です。売上に対する粗利率を百分率で小数第2位まで四捨五入して答えてください。", "expected": 89.5, "seeds": [ 17388524, 4268177492, 1902073540 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": true }, "mode": "sampling", "rep": 2, "off": { "full_completion": "{\"answer\":89.5}", "measurement": { "case": "arithmetic-018-sampling-r2-mtp0", "task": "arithmetic-018", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 1902073540, "rep": 2, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4095, "generated_tokens": 9, "first_generated_seconds": 1.512641528970562, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5323087440337986, "first_answer_seconds": 1.5323087440337986, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.6776996100088581, "generation_tps": 44.341821699382336, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "4d6b5ce4ce7798b1f41e32b5a9100717d1e0ddc2cd7e86febc007890d793ed8b", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":89.5}", "parsed": { "answer": 89.5 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "(80000-8400)/80000=0.895 → 89.50%{\"answer\":\"89.50%\"}", "measurement": { "case": "arithmetic-018-sampling-r2-mtp1", "task": "arithmetic-018", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 1902073540, "rep": 2, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4095, "generated_tokens": 31, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5654725880594924, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5654725880594924, "first_answer_seconds": 1.8048246490070596, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.9096904990728945, "generation_tps": 80.11174848949811, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 20, "rejected_draft_tokens": 13, "output_sha256": "956b6b09dde0ede9bc3d367731bdbb14a0b27131acaa887d8305f7eb952c49ee", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":\"89.50%\"}", "parsed": { "answer": "89.50%" }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } }, { "task": { "id": "code-054", "category": "code", "template_variant": 4, "question": "次のPython 3コードのprintが出力する値を答えてください。コードは実行せず読解してください。\n```python\nxs = [16, -5, 9, 6, 1, 9, 0, 3]\nprint(sum(i * x for i, x in enumerate(xs)))\n```", "expected": 101, "seeds": [ 4166874933, 332336680, 3760716714 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": false }, "mode": "sampling", "rep": 1, "off": { "full_completion": "16*0 +(-5)*1+9*2+6*3+1*4+9*5+0*6+3*7 = -5+18+18+4+45+21=101{\"answer\": 101}", "measurement": { "case": "code-054-sampling-r1-mtp0", "task": "code-054", "category": "code", "template_variant": 4, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 332336680, "rep": 1, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 55, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5196396890096366, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5196396890096366, "first_answer_seconds": 2.494132091058418, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.625869898009114, "generation_tps": 48.34066777238531, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "6cc824f3be5b67feda66dd7454d4502b9d71d3eaea78d1a307bb027f1822cba2", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\": 101}", "parsed": { "answer": 101 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "16*0 -25 +18 +24 +4 +45 +0 +21 = 87{\"answer\": 87}", "measurement": { "case": "code-054-sampling-r1-mtp1", "task": "code-054", "category": "code", "template_variant": 4, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 332336680, "rep": 1, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 28, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5738056870177388, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5738056870177388, "first_answer_seconds": 1.8812756970291957, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.9240255260374397, "generation_tps": 71.80388039260443, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 17, "rejected_draft_tokens": 16, "output_sha256": "df2599fd7f7b78a28e7cfea9c213c13b5e32ebeea98459c959b4b767e6c800d5", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\": 87}", "parsed": { "answer": 87 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } }, { "task": { "id": "logic-027", "category": "logic", "template_variant": 2, "question": "規則は「障害が発生したなら必ず通知する」です。通知が届いたという事実だけから障害発生を断定できますか。「断定できる」または「断定できない」で答えてください。なお記録番号は244541です。", "expected": "断定できない", "seeds": [ 3179642043, 3952999380, 2272891024 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": false }, "mode": "sampling", "rep": 0, "off": { "full_completion": "{\"answer\":\"断定できない\"}", "measurement": { "case": "logic-027-sampling-r0-mtp0", "task": "logic-027", "category": "logic", "template_variant": 2, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 3179642043, "rep": 0, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 9, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5188138280063868, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5385094489902258, "first_answer_seconds": 1.5385094489902258, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.7090273189824075, "generation_tps": 44.59718576427885, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "5ecb23cbfd41d73890c3dd1add61e5b195d3d416badcfcbc1523a48da5af338b", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":\"断定できない\"}", "parsed": { "answer": "断定できない" }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "{\"answer\": \"断定できる\"}", "measurement": { "case": "logic-027-sampling-r0-mtp1", "task": "logic-027", "category": "logic", "template_variant": 2, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 3179642043, "rep": 0, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 10, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5699088369728997, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5699302189750597, "first_answer_seconds": 1.5699302189750597, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.6377305120695382, "generation_tps": 89.70728542605852, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 7, "rejected_draft_tokens": 2, "output_sha256": "c2942c2ea84287c71f36afc2204ea14610789442b4bdeebc770b446dc3710a9b", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\": \"断定できる\"}", "parsed": { "answer": "断定できる" }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } }, { "task": { "id": "arithmetic-092", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 2, "question": "5403個の商品を1箱73個まで詰めます。全商品を収めるための最少の箱数は何箱ですか。", "expected": 75, "seeds": [ 1330210629, 4096328267, 1831662327 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": false }, "mode": "sampling", "rep": 1, "off": { "full_completion": "5403/73=74.01… 73×74=5402, so 75.{\"answer\":75}", "measurement": { "case": "arithmetic-092-sampling-r1-mtp0", "task": "arithmetic-092", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 2, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 4096328267, "rep": 1, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 30, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5134901909623295, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5134901909623295, "first_answer_seconds": 2.000690142973326, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.1110395160503685, "generation_tps": 47.715571065651325, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "d45a5571ecfb6a7ffe593c58607a5076de3b56c2820916e5a6c5597848b45f44", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":75}", "parsed": { "answer": 75 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "5403/73=74.01… 74箱。{\"answer\":74}", "measurement": { "case": "arithmetic-092-sampling-r1-mtp1", "task": "arithmetic-092", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 2, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 4096328267, "rep": 1, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 21, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5677278259536251, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5677278259536251, "first_answer_seconds": 1.8404071419499815, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.9173271500039846, "generation_tps": 53.421607180953536, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 10, "rejected_draft_tokens": 23, "output_sha256": "7d15928f4cc1066209814e39f636c66ac50e6dfed244c2758a5700f8ab2cfa74", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":74}", "parsed": { "answer": 74 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } }, { "task": { "id": "records-037", "category": "records", "template_variant": 2, "question": "次のJSONだけを根拠に、全行のqtyからreturnedを引いた数の合計を答えてください。\n[{\"id\": \"R01\", \"department\": \"営業\", \"qty\": 42, \"returned\": 4, \"status\": \"確定\"}, {\"id\": \"R02\", \"department\": \"開発\", \"qty\": 58, \"returned\": 2, \"status\": \"確定\"}, {\"id\": \"R03\", \"department\": \"管理\", \"qty\": 27, \"returned\": 4, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R04\", \"department\": \"開発\", \"qty\": 13, \"returned\": 0, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R05\", \"department\": \"営業\", \"qty\": 12, \"returned\": 2, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R06\", \"department\": \"管理\", \"qty\": 30, \"returned\": 0, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R07\", \"department\": \"営業\", \"qty\": 9, \"returned\": 2, \"status\": \"確定\"}, {\"id\": \"R08\", \"department\": \"管理\", \"qty\": 61, \"returned\": 4, \"status\": \"確定\"}, {\"id\": \"R09\", \"department\": \"開発\", \"qty\": 38, \"returned\": 1, \"status\": \"確定\"}, {\"id\": \"R10\", \"department\": \"開発\", \"qty\": 31, \"returned\": 4, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R11\", \"department\": \"管理\", \"qty\": 14, \"returned\": 0, \"status\": \"保留\"}, {\"id\": \"R12\", \"department\": \"営業\", \"qty\": 62, \"returned\": 3, \"status\": \"保留\"}]", "expected": 371, "seeds": [ 827600138, 4029129600, 1044193959 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": false }, "mode": "sampling", "rep": 1, "off": { "full_completion": "38+56+23+13+10+30+7+57+37+27+14+59 = 371{\"answer\":371}", "measurement": { "case": "records-037-sampling-r1-mtp0", "task": "records-037", "category": "records", "template_variant": 2, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 4029129600, "rep": 1, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 35, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5659997389884666, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5659997389884666, "first_answer_seconds": 2.1347881939727813, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.2634477500105277, "generation_tps": 47.7064092017761, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "41346347e6945bcf105df86aae0d4f2c4ac50cd47c678bca8c8f0f9bb2658ce2", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":371}", "parsed": { "answer": 371 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "38+56+23+13+10+30+7+57+37+27+14+59{\"answer\": 381}", "measurement": { "case": "records-037-sampling-r1-mtp1", "task": "records-037", "category": "records", "template_variant": 2, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 4029129600, "rep": 1, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 32, "first_generated_seconds": 1.617787973023951, "first_visible_seconds": 1.617787973023951, "first_answer_seconds": 1.9924816730199382, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.1000235420651734, "generation_tps": 60.518289521330715, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 17, "rejected_draft_tokens": 28, "output_sha256": "93c312662937c44ed6d8614fa9f8baaacccfafece03f2d344b69fa3e9c1b71b1", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\": 381}", "parsed": { "answer": 381 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } }, { "task": { "id": "arithmetic-058", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 3, "question": "売上49000円、仕入原価5900円です。売上に対する粗利率を百分率で小数第2位まで四捨五入して答えてください。", "expected": 87.96, "seeds": [ 965469572, 4019980012, 3730798878 ], "input_target": 4096, "greedy_check": false }, "mode": "sampling", "rep": 2, "off": { "full_completion": "(49000-5900)/49000=43100/49000=0.879591836…→87.96{\"answer\": 87.96}", "measurement": { "case": "arithmetic-058-sampling-r2-mtp0", "task": "arithmetic-058", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 3730798878, "rep": 2, "mtp": false, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 44, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5120164409745485, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5120164409745485, "first_answer_seconds": 2.2205644239438698, "end_to_end_seconds": 2.3850748599506915, "generation_tps": 48.23713333722037, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 0, "rejected_draft_tokens": 0, "output_sha256": "97f618f32248854e705c48229b346be10dc3f397e722464f888d6ecae2af90e9", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\": 87.96}", "parsed": { "answer": 87.96 }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": true, "natural_stop": true, "pass": true } } }, "on": { "full_completion": "(49000-5900)/49000=0.87959... → 87.96{\"answer\":\"87.96%\"}", "measurement": { "case": "arithmetic-058-sampling-r2-mtp1", "task": "arithmetic-058", "category": "arithmetic", "template_variant": 3, "mode": "sampling", "seed": 3730798878, "rep": 2, "mtp": true, "capacity": 1048576, "input_tokens": 4096, "generated_tokens": 34, "first_generated_seconds": 1.5662265919381753, "first_visible_seconds": 1.5662265919381753, "first_answer_seconds": 1.8715566439786926, "end_to_end_seconds": 1.9418647149577737, "generation_tps": 81.01107074566433, "finish_reason": "stop_token", "accepted_draft_tokens": 22, "rejected_draft_tokens": 14, "output_sha256": "474901e99f879599af9a2f29e7aeed796e681f9244f36b15d7eb493706cf2b5b", "score": { "answer": "{\"answer\":\"87.96%\"}", "parsed": { "answer": "87.96%" }, "format_valid": true, "semantic_correct": false, "natural_stop": true, "pass": false } } } } ] }, "note": "All qualifying pairs are included; observed error steps do not identify the internal numerical, RNG, cache or draft-acceptance root cause." }